Is Smart Switch Financially More Feasible?


In the realm of smart homes, two major players are reshaping our concept of domestic lighting: smart switches and smart bulbs.

Smart switches are in-wall devices that replace your traditional light switch, allowing you to control your lights remotely or set them on a schedule.

On the other hand, smart bulbs replace your standard light bulbs and offer a wide range of colors and brightness, controllable from your smartphone or smart home hub.

While these innovative technologies bring comfort and convenience to our lives, the question arises: Is opting for a smart switch more financially feasible than a smart bulb?

In this document, we aim to delve into this question and shed light on the key factors that can influence the cost-effectiveness of these two options.

Energy Consumption and Standby Mode

Like you, I was concerned about the potential drain on energy when I first considered making the switch to smart lighting.

I mean, these devices are always connected to the internet, right? Wouldn’t that mean they’re constantly using power?

To my surprise, smart switches and bulbs use a minimal amount of energy in standby mode — we’re talking about less than 0.5 watts per hour on average.

To put that in perspective, that’s less energy than it takes to charge your smartphone.

Regular Bulbs Vs. Smart Bulbs: A Cost Comparison

Next, I decided to do a little cost comparison. So I crunched some numbers, comparing the monthly running costs of regular bulbs with smart bulbs.

Here’s what I found: on average, a 60-watt regular bulb running for three hours a day would cost about $1.20 per month.

In comparison, a 9-watt smart bulb (which provides the same level of brightness) running for the same amount of time would cost about $0.18 per month. Yes, you heard that right! The savings from using smart bulbs can be dramatic.

Impact on Electricity Bills: Minimal but Meaningful

Lastly, let’s talk about the impact on the electricity bill. If you’re like me, every penny counts. To my relief, the impact of smart switches and bulbs on the electricity bill was negligible.

The small energy consumption during standby mode or even when fully operational hardly caused a noticeable increase in my monthly bill.

In fact, the energy-efficient nature of smart bulbs translated into some noticeable savings over time.

So while the initial investment may be higher for smart switches and bulbs, in the long run, they can indeed be the more cost-effective choice.

Functionality of Smart Switches

One of the most significant advantages of smart switches is their remote accessibility. I recall times when I’ve settled into bed only to realize I left a light in the living room.

With traditional lighting, it’d mean getting out of bed to turn off the light. But with smart switches, I pull out my smartphone, open the associated app, and voilà!

I can turn off the light without leaving the comfort of my blanket cocoon. It’s convenience at its finest.

Smart switches don’t just offer remote on-and-off capabilities — they can do so much more.

I’ve taken advantage of synchronized scheduling and remote dimming features, making my life considerably easier.

I’ve scheduled my living room light to dim at night, creating a cozy environment for movie nights.

Also, I have an early morning yoga routine, and I’ve set my switches to gently brighten the room as I wake, easing me into the day.

Initially, I thought having multiple smart bulbs in a room would be beneficial. However, I’ve found that using a smart switch provides more seamless control over all lights in a room.

Instead of individually controlling each bulb, I can operate the entire lighting system with a single command on one smart switch.

It’s more efficient and results in a more uniform lighting experience throughout the room.

This was particularly noticeable in my open-plan kitchen and dining area, where a single smart switch made it easier to create the perfect ambiance for dinner parties.

Considerations for Electrical Changes

Possibility of Making Substantial Electrical Changes

Before I made the switch to smart controls, I had to ask myself a hard question: was my home ready for this kind of substantial electrical change?

After all, the installation of smart switches isn’t just about snapping something new into place — it often requires a bit of electrical know-how.

I had to evaluate if my home’s electrical system, some of which was quite outdated, was up to the task. It made me pause and seriously consider the structural implications before making the leap.

Landlord Restrictions for Rewiring in Rented Spaces

For those of you who, like me, live in a rented space, there’s also the question of landlord restrictions.

When I first got the idea to install smart switches, I had a lengthy chat with my landlord about changing the electrical wiring.

It’s not something I could just decide to do on a whim. We had several discussions, and I had to assure her that I would hire a licensed electrician to do the job, which she ultimately agreed to.

Lastly, I had to ponder the future. Will I be making more wiring upgrades down the line? This question had a significant impact on my choice between smart bulbs and smart switches.

If I plan to upgrade my wiring in the future or want to add more smart features to my home, it’s essential to take this into account.

After some thought, I decided that smart switches would be a more practical choice, as they provide widespread control and can integrate seamlessly with future upgrades.

Financial Sensibility

Let’s talk dollars and cents. Equipping an entire fixture with smart bulbs can be quite costly, especially for multi-bulb fixtures.

After some number-crunching, it became clear to me that installing a smart switch was more cost-effective than buying multiple smart bulbs.

Smart switches do have a higher upfront cost, I won’t deny that. But in the long run, they can prove to be more economical.

The smart switch I installed has already outlasted several of my smart bulbs, and it controls multiple fixtures, which adds to the savings.

The initial investment for a smart switch might seem steep. I had to factor in the cost of the switch itself and the electrician’s fee to install it.

However, when I considered the potential savings over time—fewer bulb replacements and the convenience of controlling all lights from one source—I realized the benefits far outweighed the initial outlay. In the end, the smart switch proved to be a financially sensible choice for my home.


As we wrap up this enlightening journey, I’d like to recap some of the key points that led me to choose smart switches over smart bulbs for my home.

First, the versatility of smart switches was appealing, as they offered control over multiple fixtures – a clear advantage over smart bulbs.

Their ability to integrate with future upgrades was another winning point, considering my interest in continually improving my home’s tech functionality.

The financial feasibility of smart switches stood out prominently. Although the upfront cost of a smart switch was higher, it outlasted my smart bulbs and controlled multiple fixtures, making it more economical in the long run.

The cost-effectiveness of smart switches cannot be overstated; they’ve saved me a fair amount of money in bulb replacements and electric bills.

Despite my unwavering endorsement of smart switches, I’d like to stress that it’s essential for everyone to assess their unique needs and circumstances. Each home is different, and so are the people living in them.

Make sure to consider your current setup, future plans, and budget. In my case, smart switches were the clear choice, but for you, smart bulbs may be the ideal solution. It’s all about finding what works best for your home and your lifestyle. Happy home-tech hunting!

Recent Posts